The question of whether Jerome Powell should step down as Chair of the Federal Reserve has surfaced with renewed intensity in financial circles during July 2025. A prominent economist, Mohamed El-Erian, has publicly advocated for Powell’s resignation, citing concerns over the central bank’s independence and past missteps. This perspective, noted briefly via sentiment on platforms like X, is not merely a fleeting opinion but taps into deeper debates about the Fed’s credibility, policy errors, and the delicate balance of political influence over monetary policy. The sharpest concern lies in whether Powell’s tenure, marred by historical controversies and current pressures, risks undermining the institution’s ability to navigate an increasingly complex economic landscape.
Historical Context: Inflation Missteps and Insider Trading Concerns
Powell’s leadership has faced scrutiny since the post-pandemic inflationary surge, which peaked at 9.1% in June 2022 in the United States, the highest in four decades. Critics argue that the Fed was slow to react, maintaining ultra-low interest rates and expansive monetary policies well into 2021 despite early warning signs. By the time rate hikes began in March 2022, inflation had already embedded itself, necessitating aggressive tightening that risked tipping the economy into recession. Data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows inflation has since moderated to 3.0% as of June 2025, yet the initial delay remains a stain on Powell’s record.
Adding to the critique is the insider trading scandal that emerged in 2021, involving senior Fed officials. While Powell himself was not directly implicated, the episode raised questions about oversight and ethical governance under his watch. Reports from 2021, corroborated by subsequent investigations, revealed that regional Fed presidents engaged in questionable stock trades during a period of significant policy decisions. This eroded public trust at a critical juncture, a point that resonates with calls for new leadership to restore confidence.
Current Economic Pressures and Fed Independence
As of Q2 2025 (April to June), the U.S. economy presents a mixed picture. GDP growth, reported at an annualised rate of 2.8% by the Bureau of Economic Analysis, suggests resilience, yet lingering inflationary pressures and labour market softening pose challenges. The Fed’s benchmark interest rate, held at a range of 5.25% to 5.50% since mid-2023, reflects a cautious stance, with markets anticipating a potential cut in late 2025 based on futures data from CME Group. However, the central bank’s ability to act decisively is under threat from political crosswinds, particularly with speculation over executive branch influence following the 2024 U.S. election cycle.
The argument for Powell’s resignation hinges on preserving Fed independence. Critics contend that a voluntary departure could pre-empt potential conflicts with political actors who might seek to reshape monetary policy for short-term gains. Historical precedent, such as the tensions between the Fed and the Nixon administration in the 1970s, underscores the fragility of central bank autonomy during politically charged times. If Powell’s presence becomes a lightning rod for interference, the long-term credibility of the institution could suffer, a risk some economists deem unacceptable.
Counterarguments: Stability Over Symbolism
On the other side, Powell’s defenders argue that continuity is paramount during uncertain economic times. His term, set to expire in May 2026, provides a buffer against abrupt policy shifts that a sudden resignation might trigger. Market volatility, already evident with the S&P 500 fluctuating by 1.2% week-on-week in mid-July 2025 per Bloomberg data, could intensify if leadership uncertainty emerges. Moreover, Powell has overseen a gradual normalisation of policy post-2022, with balance sheet reduction progressing at a measured pace—down from a peak of $8.9 trillion in April 2022 to $7.2 trillion as of June 2025, according to Fed filings.
Replacing Powell also risks appointing a successor more susceptible to external pressures, potentially exacerbating the very independence concerns raised by critics. The process, requiring Senate confirmation, could become a political football, delaying critical decision-making at a time when global headwinds—such as geopolitical tensions and supply chain disruptions—demand steady hands.
Comparative Performance Metrics
To contextualise Powell’s tenure, a brief comparison with historical Fed chairs is illustrative. The table below, compiled from Federal Reserve historical data and inflation records, highlights key metrics during their respective periods.
| Chair | Tenure | Average Inflation Rate | Major Policy Challenge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jerome Powell | 2018–Present | 3.3% (2018–Q2 2025) | Post-Pandemic Inflation |
| Janet Yellen | 2014–2018 | 1.3% (2014–2018) | Post-2008 Recovery |
| Paul Volcker | 1979–1987 | 6.2% (1979–1987) | Stagflation |
Powell’s average inflation rate, while elevated compared to Yellen’s tenure, reflects a uniquely turbulent period. Volcker’s era, often cited as a benchmark for taming inflation, came at the cost of deep recession, a trade-off Powell has so far avoided. This suggests that while mistakes were made, the broader context tempers the case for resignation.
Conclusion: A Calculated Risk Assessment
The debate over Powell’s resignation is less about personal failing and more about institutional safeguarding. While past errors on inflation and governance provide ammunition for critics, the immediate risks of disruption and market uncertainty weigh heavily against a leadership change in 2025. The Fed’s path forward requires balancing independence with accountability, a task that may not necessitate Powell’s exit but certainly demands introspection. With economic indicators still in flux and political dynamics unpredictable, the argument for resignation, though intellectually compelling, appears premature. Stability, for now, might be the lesser evil.
References
- Axios. (2025, July 22). Scoop: El-Erian calls on Powell to resign to “protect” the Fed. Retrieved from https://www.axios.com/2025/07/22/jerome-powell-federal-reserve
- Biztoc. (2025, July 22). Jerome Powell should resign to preserve Fed independence, top economist Mohamed El-Erian says. Retrieved from https://biztoc.com/x/d3a58c2ab6f8f915
- Biztoc. (2025, July 22). This renowned economist says Powell should RESIGN to protect Fed’s ‘integrity’. Retrieved from https://biztoc.com/x/73414d838e457a37
- Bloomberg. (2025, July). S&P 500 Index Data. Retrieved from https://www.bloomberg.com/quote/SPX:IND
- Breitbart. (2025, July 22). El-Erian Calls on Powell to Resign to Protect Fed. Retrieved from https://www.breitbart.com/economy/2025/07/22/el-erian-calls-on-powell-to-resign-to-protect-fed/
- Bureau of Economic Analysis. (2025, July). Gross Domestic Product, Second Quarter 2025 (Advance Estimate). Retrieved from https://www.bea.gov/news/2025/gross-domestic-product-second-quarter-2025-advance-estimate
- Bureau of Labor Statistics. (2025, July). Consumer Price Index Summary. Retrieved from https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm
- Business Insider. (2025, July). Jerome Powell should resign to protect Fed independence, according to top economists. Retrieved from https://markets.businessinsider.com/news/stocks/jerome-powell-resign-fed-independence-top-economists-bessent-rate-cut-2025-7
- CME Group. (2025, July). FedWatch Tool. Retrieved from https://www.cmegroup.com/trading/interest-rates/countdown-to-fomc.html
- CNBC. (2025, July 22). Mohamed El-Erian says Powell should resign to preserve Fed independence. Retrieved from https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/22/mohamed-el-erian-says-powell-should-resign-to-preserve-fed-independence.html
- Federal Reserve Board. (2025, June). Balance Sheet Trends. Retrieved from https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttrends.htm
- Federal Reserve Economic Data. (2025, July). Consumer Price Index and Balance Sheet Data. Retrieved from https://fred.stlouisfed.org
- Fortune. (2025, July 22). Jerome Powell Should Resign, Top Economist Mohamed El-Erian Says. Retrieved from https://fortune.com/2025/07/22/jerome-powell-should-resign-top-economist-mohamed-el-erian-insider-trading-scandal/
- Newsmax. (2025, July 22). Mohamed El-Erian: Jerome Powell Should Resign From Fed. Retrieved from https://www.newsmax.com/politics/mohamed-el-erian-jerome-powell-federal-reserve/2025/07/22/id/1219597/
- The National News. (2025, July 22). Egyptian-American economist Mohamed El-Erian calls for Fed chairman’s resignation. Retrieved from https://www.thenationalnews.com/business/economy/2025/07/22/egyptian-american-economist-mohamed-el-erian-calls-for-fed-chairmans-resignation/
- The National Pulse. (2025, July 22). This Renowned Economist Says Powell Should RESIGN to Protect Fed’s ‘Integrity.’. Retrieved from https://thenationalpulse.com/2025/07/22/this-renowned-economist-says-powell-should-resign-to-protect-feds-integrity
- Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2022, June 15). The US annual inflation rate has accelerated to 9.1% in June of 2022, the highest since November of 1981 [Post]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1537047016064159744
- Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2023, April 27). The US economy grew at an annualized rate of 1.1% on quarter in Q1 2023, well below forecasts of 2% [Post]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1651634913748320258
- Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2024, February 13). The annual inflation rate in the US slowed to 3.1% in January 2024 from 3.4% in December [Post]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1757393434464104449
- Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2024, April 11). Jerome Powell has purchased between $1 million and $5 million of Municipal Bonds on October 1st, 2020 [Post]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1778430805288853713
- Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2024, September 24). In Q3 2024, former Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell sold over $1M of the Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Fund [Post]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1836500317648605518
- US Inflation Calculator. (2025, July). Historical Inflation Data. Retrieved from https://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-inflation-rates/
- US Senate. (2025, May). Federal Reserve Chair Term Details. Retrieved from https://www.congress.gov
