- Shift4 trades at a forward EV/EBITDA multiple of 13x, considerably lower than peers such as Toast (91x) and Block (30x), despite exhibiting strong revenue growth.
- The company reported 17% year-over-year revenue growth in Q2 2025, reaching $966.2 million, alongside compound annual growth in payment volumes exceeding 40% since 2021 projections.
- Analyst estimates suggest forward earnings per share of $4.81, translating to a P/E of 18.6 — significantly below Toast’s 125.37, underscoring potential mispricing.
- Strategic acquisitions have expanded Shift4’s platform and scale, while international expansion initiatives forecast a potential revenue CAGR of 20–25% through 2027.
- Analysts rate Shift4 a ‘Buy’, with rising EBITDA momentum and a 25-year track record of profitable growth bolstering confidence amidst competitive industry headwinds.
In the fiercely competitive payment processing industry, where giants vie for market share amid rapid technological shifts, Shift4 Payments (NYSE: FOUR) stands out for its compelling blend of robust revenue growth and undervalued multiples relative to peers. As investors navigate this landscape, the company’s ability to deliver consistent top-line expansion at a fraction of the valuation premiums commanded by competitors warrants closer scrutiny. This dynamic not only highlights potential mispricings in the sector but also underscores opportunities for those seeking growth without overpaying.
Navigating Competition in Payment Processing
The payment processing sector is a battleground of innovation and scale, with players ranging from established behemoths to agile fintech disruptors. Companies like Toast (NYSE: TOST), Fiserv (NYSE: FI), Block (NYSE: SQ, listed as XYZ in some comparisons), and PayPal (NASDAQ: PYPL) each bring unique strengths, from point-of-sale integrations to global digital wallets. Yet, amid this rivalry, Shift4 Payments has carved a niche in hospitality, sports, and entertainment verticals, leveraging integrated solutions that combine payment processing with software ecosystems. This focus has driven impressive revenue trajectories, but it’s the valuation disparity that truly piques investor interest.
Recent analyses, drawing from market data as of 26 August 2025, reveal Shift4 trading at an enterprise value to EBITDA (EV/EBITDA) multiple of approximately 13x. In contrast, peers exhibit a wide range: Toast at 91x, Fiserv at 11x, Block at 30x, and PayPal at 10x. This positioning suggests Shift4 offers growth at a discount, particularly when benchmarked against high-flyers like Toast, whose lofty multiple reflects aggressive expansion bets but also heightened risk. Such comparisons illuminate why, in a sector prone to volatility, Shift4’s metrics could signal an asymmetric upside for discerning investors.
Revenue Growth: A Key Differentiator
Shift4’s revenue story is one of sustained acceleration, outpacing many rivals in key metrics. For instance, the company reported a 17% year-over-year gross revenue increase in its second quarter of 2025, reaching $966.2 million, though this fell slightly short of consensus estimates. More tellingly, over longer horizons, Shift4 has demonstrated compound annual growth rates (CAGR) in payment volumes exceeding 40% from 2021 projections, scaling to an estimated $250 billion in total payment volume for 2025. This growth stems from organic expansions and strategic acquisitions, such as the integration of merchant bases in fragmented markets, allowing cross-selling of advanced payment technologies.
Comparatively, peers like Toast have shown strong revenue surges, with recent quarters highlighting double-digit gains fuelled by restaurant-focused POS systems. However, Toast’s growth comes at a premium, as evidenced by its elevated EV/EBITDA. Fiserv, a more mature player, boasts steady revenue from its broad financial services portfolio but trades at a modest 11x multiple, reflecting slower growth prospects. Block’s diversified ecosystem, including Cash App and Square, drives revenue diversity, yet its 30x multiple implies expectations of continued innovation amid competitive pressures. PayPal, with its vast user base, has seen revenue stabilisation but trades at just 10x, signalling market concerns over saturation and fintech disruptions.
What sets Shift4 apart is its efficiency in converting growth into profitability. Analyst models project forward earnings per share (EPS) for Shift4 at $4.81, yielding a forward P/E of 18.6 based on a share price of $89.47 as of 26 August 2025. This contrasts with Toast’s forward P/E of 125.37 at $43.88 per share, underscoring the valuation gap. Such figures, derived from consensus estimates, suggest Shift4 could achieve mid-teens revenue CAGR through 2027, supported by margin expansions from cross-selling and operational synergies.
Valuation Metrics in Context
To appreciate Shift4’s appeal, consider a peer comparison table based on key valuation and growth indicators as of 26 August 2025:
| Company | EV/EBITDA Multiple | Forward P/E | Market Cap (USD Bn) | Recent Revenue Growth (YoY) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shift4 Payments (FOUR) | 13x | 18.60 | 7.91 | 17% |
| Toast (TOST) | 91x | 125.37 | 25.58 | High double-digits (analyst est.) |
| Fiserv (FI) | 11x | 13.53 | 74.95 | Steady single-digits |
| Block (SQ/XYZ) | 30x | N/A | 48.02 | Variable, mid-teens |
| PayPal (PYPL) | 10x | 14.35 | 67.05 | Stabilising, low teens |
This snapshot, informed by market data and analyst insights, reveals Shift4’s balanced profile: growth akin to disruptors but valued like incumbents. The 13x EV/EBITDA places it in a sweet spot, potentially undervalued if revenue momentum persists. Analysts from firms like those contributing to Nasdaq compilations rate FOUR as a ‘Buy’ with an average score of 1.5, reflecting optimism around its EBITDA growth, which surged 51% year-over-year in recent reports.
Strategic Edges and Risks
Shift4’s model thrives on acquisitions that bolt on captive merchant networks, subsequently migrating them to its cloud-based platforms. This has expanded its addressable market significantly since its 2020 IPO, with payment volumes growing over 7x and adjusted EBITDA multiplying nearly 10x by mid-2025. Such strategies enhance stickiness, as seen in its dominance in hospitality POS systems, where it claims top positions.
However, risks abound in this competitive arena. Integration challenges from M&A could dilute margins, and macroeconomic headwinds might curb transaction volumes. Peers like PayPal face similar pressures, with sentiment from sources like Seeking Alpha noting concerns over consumer spending slowdowns. For Shift4, recent stock dips—trading at $89.47, down 7.6% from its 50-day average of $96.83—stem partly from a Q2 earnings miss, yet analysts view this as a buying opportunity, with raised full-year guidance signalling confidence.
Looking ahead, model-based forecasts from platforms like PitchBook project Shift4’s revenue CAGR at 20–25% through 2027, driven by international expansions into over 65 countries. If achieved, this could compress its EV/EBITDA further, potentially aligning it closer to Fiserv’s stability while retaining growth appeal. Investor sentiment, as gauged by Benzinga reports, shows declining short interest, indicating reduced bearish bets.
Implications for Investors
In a sector where valuations can swing wildly on growth narratives, Shift4 Payments exemplifies the allure of disciplined expansion at reasonable prices. Its 13x EV/EBITDA, juxtaposed against peers’ premiums, positions it as a potential compounder for long-term holders. While the industry remains cutthroat, Shift4’s track record—spanning 25 years of profitable growth—suggests it could continue outperforming expectations.
Investors weighing entry should monitor upcoming earnings on 5 November 2025 for Block and 28 October 2025 for PayPal, as these could influence sector multiples. Ultimately, in payment processing’s high-stakes game, Shift4’s valuation-growth nexus offers a pragmatic path amid the hype.
References
- Forbes. (n.d.). Shift4 Payments Company Profile. https://www.forbes.com/companies/shift4-payments/
- PitchBook. (n.d.). Shift4 Payments Profile. https://pitchbook.com/profiles/company/96968-98
- Nasdaq. (n.d.). Assessing Shift4 Payments: Insights from 15 Financial Analysts. https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/assessing-shift4-payments-insights-15-financial-analysts
- Simply Wall St. (n.d.). Shift4 Payments Valuation. https://simplywall.st/stocks/us/diversified-financials/nyse-four/shift4-payments/valuation
- QualityStocks Substack. (n.d.). Shift4 Payments: The Next Big Player. https://qualitystocks.substack.com/p/shift4-payments-the-next-big-player
- DCFModelling. (n.d.). Shift4 SWOT Analysis. https://dcfmodeling.com/products/four-swot-analysis
- StockAnalysis. (n.d.). Shift4 Stock Overview. https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/four/
- Benzinga. (2025, August). Executive Chairman at Shift4 Payments Buys $16.27M of Stock. https://benzinga.com/insights/news/25/08/47063243/executive-chairman-at-shift4-payments-buys-16-27m-of-stock
- Benzinga. (2025, August). Market Sentiment Around Shift4 Payments. https://www.benzinga.com/insights/short-sellers/25/08/47281844/whats-driving-the-market-sentiment-around-shift4-payments
- Yahoo Finance. (2025, August). Why Shift4 Payments Stock Is Falling. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/why-shift4-payments-stock-falling-174041113.html
- Seeking Alpha. (2025). Shift4 Payments Stock: Keep Buying the Dip. https://seekingalpha.com/article/4811951-shift4-payments-stock-keep-buying-dip-do-not-look-back
- Yahoo Finance. (2025, August). Shift4 Payments Misses Q2 Earnings. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/shift4-payments-misses-q2-earnings-114602605.html
- TradingView. (2025). Shift4 Payments Inc. SEC 10-Q Report. https://tradingview.com/news/tradingview:1c248c87fa52a:0-shift4-payments-inc-sec-10-q-report
- AINVEST. (2025). Shift4 Payments Dip Presents High-Conviction Buy Opportunity. https://ainvest.com/news/shift4-payments-dip-presents-high-conviction-buy-opportunity-2508
- Rook, I. (2025). Shift4 commentary via X. https://x.com/rookisaacman/status/1856498331075174476
- FonsDK. (2025). Market insights via X. https://x.com/FonsDK/status/1631705677428060160
- Shift4 Official. (2025). Company statements via X. https://x.com/Shift4/status/1930625820189446285
