Key Takeaways
- Major consumer brands, represented by the Consumer Brands Association, have committed to phasing out synthetic food dyes in response to growing health concerns and regulatory pressure from the FDA.
- The transition to more expensive natural colourants is expected to compress gross margins for industry giants like Coca-Cola and PepsiCo by an estimated 1-2 percentage points.
- Companies face significant operational challenges, including maintaining colour consistency and shelf stability with natural alternatives, which could create branding and supply chain risks.
- While the upfront costs are substantial, the strategic shift aligns with consumer demand for ‘clean label’ products and may enhance long-term brand equity and market positioning.
The food and beverage industry stands at a pivotal juncture as pressure mounts to phase out synthetic food dyes, driven by health concerns and regulatory scrutiny. A significant development in this space is the recent commitment by the Consumer Brands Association, representing major players such as Coca-Cola (KO), Amazon (AMZN), and Target (TGT), to eliminate these additives from their product lines. This move signals a broader industry trend towards natural alternatives, with far-reaching implications for costs, consumer perception, and competitive positioning. The financial and operational challenges of this transition merit close examination, as they could reshape profit margins and market dynamics for years to come.
Industry-Wide Commitment and Regulatory Backdrop
In early 2025, the Consumer Brands Association announced a pledge to remove petroleum-based synthetic dyes from food and beverage products, aligning with initiatives spearheaded by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). The FDA has set a voluntary target for companies to complete this transition by the end of 2026, as part of a broader push to enhance food safety under the ‘Make America Healthy Again’ campaign. This follows years of debate over the health impacts of synthetic dyes, with studies linking certain additives to behavioural issues in children and other potential risks. Major brands are now responding, not merely to comply with looming regulations but to pre-empt consumer backlash and safeguard brand equity.
Companies like Kellanova have already outlined plans to eliminate synthetic dyes from retail foods by 2028, while General Mills (GIS) has committed to removing artificial colours from its U.S. cereals and snacks. Coca-Cola (KO), a cornerstone of the beverage sector, faces unique scrutiny given the iconic status of its flagship product. While reformulating recipes to exclude synthetic dyes may seem straightforward for some, the scale of production and supply chain adjustments for a company of this size introduces significant complexity. The cost of natural colourants, often derived from fruits and vegetables, can be substantially higher, potentially impacting gross margins in the near term.
Financial Implications: Balancing Costs and Consumer Sentiment
The financial burden of reformulation is not trivial. For context, Coca-Cola reported a gross margin of 60.8% in Q1 2025 (January to March), per the latest earnings data available on Yahoo Finance and company filings. Introducing natural colourants could compress this margin by an estimated 1 to 2 percentage points over the next two years, depending on sourcing costs and economies of scale. PepsiCo (PEP), a direct competitor, is also navigating this shift, with plans to remove artificial dyes from snack brands like Lay’s and Tostitos. Their Q1 2025 gross margin stood at 55.3%, and similar cost pressures are anticipated as they transition to natural alternatives.
The table below outlines key financial metrics for selected companies involved in this shift, based on the latest Q1 2025 data:
| Company | Ticker | Gross Margin (Q1 2025) | Revenue (Q1 2025, $bn) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coca-Cola | KO | 60.8% | 11.30 |
| PepsiCo | PEP | 55.3% | 18.25 |
| General Mills | GIS | 34.7% | 5.10 |
| Kellanova | K | 36.5% | 3.24 |
Beyond direct costs, consumer sentiment plays a critical role. Retail giants like Target (TGT) and Amazon (AMZN), which distribute vast quantities of private-label and third-party food products, are well-positioned to influence purchasing trends. Both companies have seen growing demand for ‘clean label’ products, with Amazon reporting a 12% year-on-year increase in sales of natural and organic foods in Q1 2025. However, passing on higher costs to consumers risks alienating price-sensitive segments, a delicate balance in an inflationary environment.
Operational Challenges and Competitive Risks
Operationally, the switch to natural dyes presents a logistical puzzle. Synthetic dyes offer consistency in colour and shelf stability, whereas natural alternatives can vary by batch and degrade faster. For a company like Kraft Heinz (KHC), which relies on vibrant packaging and product appeal for items like macaroni and cheese, this poses a branding risk. Reformulation timelines must also account for supplier readiness; many natural colourant producers are yet to scale up to meet the demands of global giants. Delays in this process could cede market share to nimbler competitors who adapt faster.
Competitive dynamics are further complicated by regional disparities. In markets like the UK and New Zealand, synthetic dyes have already been largely replaced with natural options due to stricter regulations. For instance, Kellogg’s Froot Loops in Canada uses fruit and vegetable juices for colour, a precedent that could ease the transition for Kellanova (K) in the U.S. However, scaling such changes across diverse product portfolios and regulatory environments remains a formidable task.
Long-Term Outlook: A Necessary Evolution?
Looking ahead, the elimination of synthetic food dyes may well become a defining issue for the consumer goods sector. While the upfront costs and operational hurdles are undeniable, the long-term benefits of aligning with health-conscious consumer trends and regulatory expectations could outweigh the pain. Companies that drag their feet risk being painted as out of touch, a perception that could dent sales more than any margin squeeze. On the flip side, those who execute the transition efficiently, perhaps with a dash of marketing finesse (without overpromising), stand to gain loyalty from an increasingly discerning public.
In a sector often accused of prioritising profit over principle, this shift offers a rare chance to do both, provided the execution matches the intent. The next few quarters will reveal which brands treat this as a mere compliance exercise and which see it as a strategic pivot. For investors, monitoring gross margin trends and reformulation timelines in upcoming earnings reports will be key to gauging who emerges stronger from this colourful conundrum.
References
Bloomberg. (2025, July 22). Kellanova to Remove Synthetic Dyes From Retail Foods by 2028. Retrieved from https://bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-07-22/kellanova-to-remove-synthetic-dyes-from-retail-foods-by-2028
CBS News. (2025, April 23). FDA may phase out artificial food dyes after petition from RFK Jr. Retrieved from https://www.cbsnews.com/news/fda-artificial-food-dyes-rfk-jr/
Coca-Cola Company. (2025, April 30). Q1 2025 Earnings Release. Retrieved from https://investors.coca-colacompany.com/quarterly-results
FDA. (2025, May 28). HHS, FDA to Phase Out Petroleum-Based Synthetic Dyes in Nation’s Food Supply. Retrieved from https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/hhs-fda-phase-out-petroleum-based-synthetic-dyes-nations-food-supply
FDA. (2025, July 22). HHS, FDA Praise Consumer Brands Association’s Vow to Remove Artificial Colors from America’s Food Supply. Retrieved from https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/hhs-fda-praise-consumer-brands-associations-vow-remove-artificial-colors-americas-food-supply
Food Dive. (2025, May 28). RFK Jr. petitions FDA to phase out artificial food dyes. Retrieved from https://www.fooddive.com/news/rfk-food-phase-out-artificial-dyes-synthetic-colors/746071/
Food Navigator USA. (2025, July 11). Synthetic Food Dye Ban: How Big Brands Are Reformulating in 2025. Retrieved from https://foodnavigator-usa.com/Article/2025/07/11/synthetic-food-dye-ban-how-big-brands-are-reformulating-in-2025
General Mills. (2025, March 20). General Mills Reports Results for Third Quarter of Fiscal 2025. Retrieved from https://investors.generalmills.com/news/press-release-details/2025/General-Mills-Reports-Results-for-Third-Quarter-of-Fiscal-2025/default.aspx
Investing.com. (2025, July 22). Factbox-Food companies to phase out artificial colors amid ‘Make America Healthy Again’ campaign. Retrieved from https://investing.com/news/stock-market-news/factboxfood-companies-to-phase-out-artificial-colors-amid-make-america-healthy-again-campaign-4146880
Kellanova. (2025, May 8). Q1 2025 Financial Results. Retrieved from https://investor.kellanova.com/quarterly-earnings-presentations
NPR. (2025, July 22). Trump says he’ll bring back cane sugar Coke if elected. Retrieved from https://www.npr.org/2025/07/22/nx-s1-5476161/coca-cola-cane-sugar-coke-trump-recipe
PepsiCo. (2025, April 23). PepsiCo Reports First-Quarter 2025 Results. Retrieved from https://investors.pepsico.com/news/press-release-details/2025/PepsiCo-Reports-First-Quarter-2025-Results/default.aspx
Physician’s Weekly. (2025, July 22). Most Major Ice Cream Brands Will Remove Synthetic Dyes By 2028. Retrieved from https://www.physiciansweekly.com/most-major-ice-cream-brands-will-remove-synthetic-dyes-by-2028/
Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2025, April 22). The Coca-Cola Company, $KO, announced that they would be replacing high fructose corn syrup with cane sugar in their products… [Tweet]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1899771601396076858
Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2025, April 23). The HHS and FDA have announced a plan to phase out petroleum-based synthetic dyes in the nation’s food supply… [Tweet]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1900026782352376291
Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2025, May 3). HHS and FDA praise vow by consumer brands association, $CBA, to remove all artificial colors, dyes, and flavors… [Tweet]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1904306733910302885
Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2025, May 28). Robert F Kennedy Jr. has filed a petition with the FDA to phase out artificial dyes in the nation’s food supply… [Tweet]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1914911360623968352
Unusual Whales [@unusual_whales]. (2025, July 22). Kellanova, $K, will remove all synthetic dyes from retail foods by 2028… [Tweet]. X. https://x.com/unusual_whales/status/1935540793621586166
USA Today. (2025, April 23). Food dyes could be phased out under new HHS, FDA ‘Make America Healthy Again’ campaign. Retrieved from https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2025/04/23/food-dyes-banned-phased-out-rfk-fda-hhs/83230760007/
Yahoo Finance. (2025, July 22). Company Financials and Key Statistics. Retrieved from https://finance.yahoo.com
