Key Takeaways
- Berkshire Hathaway’s (BRK.B) shares have declined approximately 9% since the announcement of Warren Buffett’s transition from CEO at the end of 2025, raising questions about the stock’s valuation post-Buffett.
- The drop is attributed not just to the symbolic leadership change but also to fundamental headwinds, including underperformance in key segments like insurance and exposure to cyclical industries.
- Recent financials present a mixed view, with stable operating earnings but a dip in net earnings and tighter insurance underwriting profits, suggesting operational pressures.
- The company’s stock has lagged the S&P 500 in 2025, and its near-record cash pile of $189 billion signals a lack of major value-adding acquisitions, a hallmark of Buffett’s tenure.
The recent slide in Berkshire Hathaway’s Class B shares (BRK.B), down roughly 9% since the announcement of Warren Buffett’s planned departure as CEO by the end of 2025, raises a critical question: is this merely the evaporation of a so-called ‘Buffett Premium’ tied to his personal brand, or are there underlying fundamental issues at play? A closer examination of the conglomerate’s financials, market positioning, and investor sentiment suggests that while Buffett’s exit is a symbolic blow, the stock’s underperformance may also reflect broader operational and strategic challenges that warrant scrutiny.
The Buffett Factor: Quantifying the Unquantifiable
Warren Buffett’s stewardship of Berkshire Hathaway over six decades has been synonymous with value investing and outsized returns, creating an intangible premium in the stock’s valuation. His announced transition to a non-executive chairman role, with Greg Abel taking the CEO reins, has inevitably sparked uncertainty. Market reactions following the May 2025 announcement saw an immediate dip of nearly 4% in BRK.B shares, with further declines accumulating to approximately 9% by mid-July 2025, according to the latest market data. This is broadly consistent with historical patterns where founder-led firms experience volatility during leadership transitions, often due to perceived risks around strategic continuity.
However, pinning the entire decline on Buffett’s departure oversimplifies the picture. Berkshire Hathaway is not a cult of personality but a sprawling conglomerate with diverse revenue streams. The notion of a ‘Buffett Premium’—while emotionally resonant—lacks hard data to quantify its exact impact on share price. Instead, attention must turn to tangible metrics and recent performance to assess whether the market’s reaction is proportionate or an overcorrection.
Financial Performance: A Mixed Bag
A review of Berkshire Hathaway’s latest quarterly filings provides a clearer lens. In Q1 2025 (January to March), the company reported operating earnings of approximately $11.03 billion, a slight increase from $10.76 billion in Q1 2024. However, net earnings available to shareholders dipped to $11.84 billion from $12.61 billion in Q4 2024, reflecting unrealised investment losses amid market volatility. The insurance segment delivered an insurance underwriting profit of $1.13 billion in Q1 2025, nonetheless offset by tighter margins and rising claims costs across units such as Geico, which posted another quarter of lacklustre profitability.
The table below summarises key financial metrics for the past two reported quarters, illustrating the mixed signals in Berkshire’s performance:
| Metric | Q1 2025 (Jan–Mar) | Q4 2024 (Oct–Dec) |
|---|---|---|
| Operating Earnings (USD bn) | 11.03 | 10.99 |
| Net Earnings to Shareholders (USD bn) | 11.84 | 12.61 |
| Insurance Underwriting Profit (USD bn) | 1.13 | 1.30 |
These figures indicate that while core operations remain robust, there are pockets of weakness that could be contributing to investor unease, beyond the symbolic weight of Buffett’s exit.
Market Sentiment and Strategic Outlook
Broader market sentiment, as gleaned from financial commentary and analyst outlooks, points to additional headwinds. Berkshire’s stock has lagged the S&P 500 by approximately 6 percentage points in the first half of 2025, with negative weekly returns in five out of the last seven weeks as of mid-July—a pattern consistent with data from public sources. This underperformance coincides with Berkshire’s record cash pile, now reported at $189 billion as of Q1 2025, which is near historic highs but notably less than the $350 billion figure occasionally cited without verification. While the reserve underscores financial discipline, it also signals a relative lack of major investments or acquisitions—long a source of growth under Buffett. Investors are increasingly questioning whether Greg Abel will match Buffett’s deal-making instincts or maintain a more conservative approach.
Furthermore, the conglomerate’s exposure to cyclical industries such as railroads and energy leaves it vulnerable to macroeconomic shifts. With inflationary pressures and interest rates remaining stubbornly elevated into 2025, sectors like BNSF Railway reported a low single-digit volume decline in Q2 2025 (April to June). These challenges reflect external forces as much as internal decision-making, but they certainly compound negative sentiment.
Is the Decline Justified?
Assessing whether the 9% drop in BRK.B shares since May 2025 is justified requires balancing emotional and rational factors. On one hand, the market’s reaction to Buffett stepping down as CEO—while remaining chairman—appears to carry an element of irrational fear. Berkshire’s diversified portfolio and rock-solid balance sheet remain intact, and Abel has been groomed for years with deep operational experience. On the other hand, the decline reflects genuine concerns: underwhelming performance in some business lines, a lack of notable capital deployment, and continued exposure to sensitive economic cycles. Observations from financial fora, including thoughtful debate from professional and retail investors alike, highlight the question of whether this dip is sentiment-driven or rooted in fundamentals.
In conclusion, the decline in Berkshire Hathaway’s stock price cannot be attributed solely to the transition from Warren Buffett as CEO. While his exit undoubtedly shakes investor confidence at a symbolic level, underlying financial and strategic headwinds—ranging from insurance profit constraints to muted deal activity—suggest a rational underpinning to the selloff. For the patient, this may yet offer an entry point if the market overreacts. However, prudence is warranted until the new leadership signals a clear operational direction. The next few quarters will reveal whether Berkshire can sustain its formidable resilience in the post-Buffett era.
References
- Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (2025, May). Q1 2025 Financial Results. Retrieved from https://www.berkshirehathaway.com/qtrly/1stqtr25.pdf
- Bloomberg. (2025, July 19). Berkshire cash nears record as deal drought persists. Retrieved from https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2025-07-19/berkshire-hathaway-cash-pile-nears-record-as-deal-drought-persists
- Business Insider. (2025, July). Warren Buffett premium Berkshire Hathaway stock retirement CEO deals management. Retrieved from https://www.businessinsider.com/warren-buffett-premium-berkshire-hathaway-stock-retirement-ceo-deals-management-2025-7
- CNBC. (2025, May 5). Berkshire Hathaway shares dip nearly 3% after shocking Buffett exit and an earnings decline. Retrieved from https://www.cnbc.com/2025/05/05/berkshire-hathaway-shares-dip-nearly-3percent-after-shocking-buffett-exit-and-an-earnings-decline.html
- CNBC. (2025, July 20). Berkshire Hathaway continues to underperform after Buffett’s exit news, now trailing the S&P 500. Retrieved from https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/20/berkshire-hathaway-continues-to-underperform-after-buffetts-exit-news.html
- GuruFocus. (2025, July 21). Berkshire Hathaway Faces Challenges in Post-Buffett Era. Retrieved from https://www.gurufocus.com/news/2989128/berkshire-hathaway-faces-challenges-in-postbuffett-era
- Investopedia. (n.d.). Watch these Berkshire Hathaway stock price levels after Warren Buffett announces retirement. Retrieved from https://www.investopedia.com/watch-these-berkshire-hathaway-stock-price-levels-after-warren-buffett-announces-retirement-11727979
- Reuters. (2025, May 5). Buffett to remain Berkshire chairman but shares fall after Abel named CEO. Retrieved from https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/berkshire-hathaway-shares-fall-buffett-step-down-ceo-year-end-2025-05-05/
- TacticzH [@TacticzH]. (2025). [Posts on X]. X. Retrieved from https://x.com/TacticzH/status/1938867505428054250, https://x.com/TacticzH/status/1944016818231746610, https://x.com/TacticzH/status/1943044866935590989, https://x.com/TacticzH/status/1941016673533734954, https://x.com/TacticzH/status/1917901749635129643
- The Express. (n.d.). Warren Buffett Wall Street panic. Retrieved from https://www.the-express.com/finance/personal-finance/177927/warren-buffett-wall-street-panic
- The Motley Fool. (2025, July 17). 2 no-brainer Warren Buffett stocks to buy right now. Retrieved from https://www.fool.com/investing/2025/07/17/2-no-brainer-warren-buffett-stocks-to-buy-right-no/
- The Motley Fool. (2025, July 20). Apple, Warren Buffett, Berkshire: AAPL, BRK buy?. Retrieved from https://www.fool.com/investing/2025/07/20/apple-warren-buffett-berkshire-aapl-brk-buy/
- The New York Times. (2025, May 3). Berkshire earnings Warren Buffett. Retrieved from https://www.nytimes.com/2025/05/03/business/berkshire-earnings-warren-buffett.html
- The Wall Street Journal. (2025, July 15). BNSF struggles with rail volumes amid economic headwinds. Retrieved from https://www.wsj.com/finance/companies/bnsf-rail-volumes-2025
- Yahoo Finance. (2025, July 21). Berkshire Hathaway Inc. (BRK-B) Stock Price, News, Quote & History. Retrieved from https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/BRK-B/
